[ Fish... This is certainly not helping with the lingering question of what she is, but it still feels too rude and therefore opening up the possibility of a similar question in return. He'll have to simply sit with this curiosity and be patient, annoying as it may be. ]

Well... [ He considers it quite seriously, it seems, even taking up a thoughtful gesture ] Considering the affliction of this town, shall we say, I do not know if I can promise a Bluefish in particular. However, surely there are fish to be found.

[ He nods ]

I suppose I can make that effort, though not quickly, I imagine. Fishing is a rather patient art.